Not itchy at all! Arrived new with tags. I wore this super pregnant with twins and it wasn't long enough to cover my bump but it was comfy and loose.

it was so hard to not buy this haha, loved this sweater. versatile, comfortable, and warm without being suffocating

I wore this for work and for a city day and dinner. It kept me warm, was soft, and overall a great top

I got this one new with tags, and it had bits of fuzz hanging off it already. It's a mixed fabric with alpaca wool in it, so I think it just has perma fuzz. But it was comfortable, a tiny bit itchy on my neck at first, but then stopped itching and was just cozy and soft. It's really versatile. Kinda oversized and sleeves are long. Wore it with a corduroy skirt and over an RTR Tanya Taylor dress and I could have styled it many more ways I think

I got this sweater to have fun pairing the stripes with patterns. The sleeve length goes down to my fingers, the neck hole is loose - this is a layering sweater... to floppy to wear on its own

Good reliable basic sweater. Ever so slightly itchy, but still very soft (wore long sleeves t-shirt under). Fit nicely on my 5’11” frame and arms were perfect length. Good for everyday use.

I loved this sweater and ended up buying it. The sleeves were too long for me (as others mentioned), but I am short so just rolled them up. I loved the fun pattern and how comfortable it was.

I absolutely loved this sweater! The arm length is great for tall girlies, I love the fun print and wear this all the time! Thick and warm, slightly cropped which is perfect for high waist pants.

L is a cozy oversized fit for me. M would have worked, too. Someone commented on the sleeve length in their reviews and they are very long, but totally fine when rolled.

I loved the little bit of extra sleeve length. It was soft and fit well.

The fit was comfy and warm

True to size, great daily wear in winter and not itchy.

Can go from sidelines of kids soccer game to dinner with friends. Loved it.

Fit great, arms a little long but I'm petite. Loved for a cozy sweater at home or work.

A little itchy nice oversized fit

I loved this sweat - so comfortable and easy

Cozy and soft, great for winter. Wore to work but also on the weekend. The arms were pretty long so I folded the cuff and it wasn't an issue.

I found myself wearing this again and again

Loved this sweater. Can't wait to rent again. Very comfy and pretty warm as well.

True to size. Great winter sweater

Warm but light weight. Not itchy. Came new with tags. I'd consider the fit slightly oversized. Small is my usual size but I wore this 6 to 8 weeks post partum so I'm more of a medium at the moment.

Fits great very comfortable and looks great. It's warm, wear it as is for fall.

Fit tts. Nice comfy basic sweater with a fun pattern.

This sweater got so many compliments. I ordered a size up because I like my sweaters oversized but with this one I should not have. Very flattering and a fun pattern!

Tons of compliments, super comfortable, absolutely loved it!

Really nice sweater. Warm, comfortable, and cute.

The sweater pops with a collar! Otherwise it’s nothing special

Sleeves were a little long but they looked fine rolled up. Cute sweater, went great with jeans.

This comfy, boxy sweater was great paired with black leggings for wine tasting or a black pencil skirt for work! It runs big, but that is the style.

Loved it so much I had to buy it.

Love the long sleeves and it’s nice and warm.

Fit well. Easy to wear!

Comfy and worn. Would rent again or even buy.

This goes with everything and is comfortable. My go-to that I wore the most.

Great with jeans or leggings! I received so many compliments. Warm and cozy.

A quality piece from Madewell with a fun mixed print. Will be renting again!

Complimented the first time in public. I told them I rented it. They thought i was kidding. RTR may have a new customer...

If your eyes are sensitive skip this one. Lots of loose fuzz. Cute though, if your eyes can handle it.